ARC News Service

The population of almost quarter of England is in imminent danger of losing the right to local democracy and representation.

The government is pushing ahead with implementing the proposals in Julian Glover’s Landscapes Review. In this it is proposed to create a new quango (non-departmental public body) called the National Landscapes Service to oversee the 44 National Parks and Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty (AONBs) covering almost 24.5 per cent of England and with more planned (Glover Review page 20).  The small Board of this Service would be appointed by Defra  and would appoint all the Board members of the National Parks and AONBs. The Secretary of State would appoint the chairs of those Boards. (Glover Review page 140)

In addition, the Glover Review proposes that the Boards of National Parks should be reduced to between nine and 12. On June 20, to fend off this drastic cut, members of the Yorkshire Dales National Park Authority (YDNPA) agreed to reduce its membership from 25 to 16 – a move which one member described as Death of Democracy in the Dales.

The YDNPA CEO, David Butterworth, told members: The introduction of a National Landscape Service … is proceeding at an astonishing pace.’ And one member commented: ‘We have got an express train heading towards us.’ See: Death of Local Democracy in National Parks?

The National Landscape Service, as a non-departmental public body, will be filled with government appointed members who never need to be legitimised by the electorate, but can rely on governmental power and influence.  There will be no democratic input or scrutiny.

And why do we need it? Because, the Review argues, the National Parks and AONBs are paid for out of our taxes. But this new body will also have to be paid for by taxpayers, just adding another layer of costs and bureaucracy.

Nor does it take into consideration the large cost of maintaining the infrastructure in National Parks and  AONBs which is borne by local authorities; or that the vast majority of the maintenance of these special areas is carried out by farmers and landowners who own the land (NOT the government or the National Trust). Yet they will have even less democratic input than they have now. Like others living in these areas they will be disenfranchised at the local level.

Also see the response to the Glover Review by the North Yorkshire Moors NPA.

If you are concerned about this please do write to your MP.

The objectives of the  Association of Rural Communities have always included the need for local democracy and representation.

When, in 2009,  local newspapers stopped sending reporters to YDNPA meetings the Association of Rural Communities was very concerned at the lack of independent reporting especially as the YDNPA has such a major impact upon those living and working in the Yorkshire Dales National Park.

It is very encouraged that there is now a Local Democracy Reporter (Stuart Minting) reporting on YDNPA meetings. Pip continues to post reports so as to continue as full a record as possible, especially of planning committee meetings.

Members of the Association’s committee regularly monitor and report on YDNPA  planning meetings – see below.

The Association’s chairman, Alastair Dinsdale, has highlighted the importance of farmers to the beautiful landscape of the Yorkshire Dales.

YDNPA planning committee reports:

July 2020

June 2020

May 2020

March 2020

February 2020

December 2019  – includes links to reports from the Full Authority meeting

November 2019

October 2019

September 2019

August 2019

In July 2019

     July 2019

In June 2019:

June 2019 reports

Hawes barn conversion refused

Proposed barn conversion at Hawes

May 2019

April 2019

March 2019

February 2019

December 2018 – the cost of the boundary extension

December 2018 – Barns and Yurts

YDNPA and the conversion of traditional barns

Tup Gill Lathe appeal decision

February to November 2018

February to December 2017

February to December 2016

Retirement of Harold Brown

February to December 2015

March 2015  – telecommunications aerials at West Witton

YDNPA Planning Committee 2013 (pdf)

February to December 2013

Inconsistencies and gobbledygook revisited

A call for justice answered

A call for justice

February to December 2012

YDNPA – inconsistencies and gobbledygook – more from the October 2012 planning committee meeting

January to December 2011

YDNPA Planning Committee 2010 (pdf)

Bishopdale 2010 – a question of consistency

Full Authority Meetings:

Full Authority September 2019  – two reports:  YDNPA and John Blackie  and  YDNPA and farming in the Dales

Full Authority March 2019: there were two reports posted on the Richmondshire Today website written by the Local Democracy reporter – one concerning the approved plan for new local occupancy housing behind the Rose and Crown and the other regarding whether the YDNPA should go paperless or not.

Full Authority reports 2017 and 2018

Full Authority reports 2015 to 2016

Full Authority reports 2012 to 2014

Full Authority reports 2011